Reservation
+1 208-938-5185
Visit Us
404 S Eagle Rd, Eagle, ID 83616, United States
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Trying out this Italian restaurant out after reading about it on social media. It is a small place with light employees there and they all gave very good service. The price point for the food is at a very reasonable rate. The service was on point and the atmosphere was quiet and delightful. My next trip will be to have the angry angle haired pasta with the medium spicy sauce. The flat bread was pretty good. ”
“ We LOVE The Stuffed Olive (affectionately called “TSO” for short). It’s a cozy, little Italian restaurant serving some of the best food out there! Everything on the menu is chef’s kiss delicious. You cannot go wrong with any of the soups, salads, sandwiches, or pasta dishes. It is alllllllll delectable! For starters, do yourself a kindness and order a plate of the parmesan fries. Most people will suggest getting it with fry sauce, but, just so you know, they also have the good ranch. All sauces are made in-house including their Caesar salad dressing, which they make the traditional way (with anchovies). You’re welcome. TSO’s Alfredo sauce is amazing. I slept on their Alfredo menu items for months because I just assumed it would all taste similar to the stuff I’ve picked up in the freezer section. Bah! How wrong I was!!! Bless my husband for ordering TSO’s Alfredo time and time again. I finally took a bite off his plate and life hasn’t been the same since that moment. Their Alfredo is melt-in-your-mouth transformative. I can never go back to freezer Alfredo again. I’m spoiled by the good stuff at TSO. The parmigiana chicken is also incredible!! I love the way they bread their chicken. It is so CRUNCHY. Everything on the menu truly is awesome, and you’ll be hard-pressed to find another Italian food spot that matches the taste and quality produced by TSO. If you’re a regular at TSO, then you already know!! For newcomers reading this review, call TSO and make that reservation! Take the day off from cooking and allow TSO to do the heavy lifting. **Seriously, though, make a resy. Do not attempt to just walk in and get a table, because it will likely not happen and you will be sad. The place fills up faaaast! TSO is family-owned and operated. Additionally, everyone on staff has been working there literally for YEARS. I do not use the word literally lightly. Great food aside, the staff has won our hearts! Every time we go to TSO, it feels like we are dropping in on some of our favorite relatives. Everyone is kind and welcoming and accommodating. They work hard to ensure their guests, the customers, have a solid dining experience. I cannot recommend this place enough. Come and see for yourself why The Stuffed Olive gets all our love! ”
“ My new favorite restaurant! Food was hot, fresh and absolutely delicious. I didn’t even get a picture of my meal because I was too busy burning my mouth on it while I wolfed it down. It was the chicken parm and it was YUM! I can’t stand when food is cold and this food was right out of the oven which was much appreciated. Great portions, clean and comfortable and stellar staff. I made the mistake of NOT getting the garlic parm fries for an appetizer and then had to sneak them off my son’s plate when he wasn’t looking. Those are addicting. My advice: GET THE FRIES! I can’t wait to go back and try more things. ”
“ Best lasagna I’ve ever had. Our server was very kind and helpful. Small and cozy. Our first time there and will go back. Highly recommend. Suggest you do make a reservation. ”
“ I showed up with my Open Table reservation in hand, they couldn’t. Find me on their list and said they didn’t use open table for reservations. However they were apologetic and patient, quickly getting a table ready for me. As I waited, I noticed my reservation was for the Stuffed Olive in England....OK they passed the stupid customer test with great service. The food was amazing, I got the mushroom Marsala with the Italian sausage. I planned to only eat half of it but none survived. I didn’t lick the plate, but thought about I!!! Quiet atmosphere, great service, I thought the prices were very reasonable! ”
“ My absolute favorite italian restaurant. I have been so many times at this point. The food is fresh and flavorful, the staff is friendly and welcoming, and the environment is relaxing and well decorated. Not to mention their prices are great. I always try to bring friends to try the food when I can. Also, as someone who hated alcohol, I actually got to enjoy wine eating here. I recommend the lava cap chardonnay. ”
“ This place was very good and I loved the outdoor seating on a nice day. I looked around at the other tables and it appeared everyone else was also enjoying their experience. The pasta here was great. We ordered shrimp scampi, Cesar salad, portobello Marciano pasta, and it also came with bread/sauce. I'm not sure what the sauce was that came with it but I enjoyed it! If I'm ever in this area again I'll definitely stop by! ”
“ The food here is very good. I got the create your own pasta with the fried chicken, the other part of my group went for the shrimp scampi and the salmon salad. Everything was very good and cooked perfectly. We had the garlic fries for a starter and they are delicious. We will be back. Thank you for the quality place to eat. ”
About
The Stuffed Olive
Welcome to The Stuffed Olive, a hidden gem tucked away in Eagle, Idaho, where the essence of Italian cuisine comes alive. Located at 404 S Eagle Rd, this family-owned restaurant is making waves in the culinary scene, and for good reason. With a reputation built on fresh ingredients and genuine hospitality, it’s no wonder that locals and visitors alike are falling head over heels for this cozy spot.
As soon as you step inside, you’ll be embraced by a warm and inviting atmosphere. Patrons rave about the attentive service, which exudes the charm of a family gathering. Regulars often describe it affectionately as “TSO,” a nod to the personality and warmth that permeates the restaurant. With employees who’ve been part of the family for years, you're not just a diner—you're part of a community.
The menu at The Stuffed Olive is a celebration of Italian comfort food. From the first bite of the acclaimed parmesan fries to the last scoop of their transformative Alfredo sauce, every dish is crafted with passion and a distinct attention to detail. Customers rave about the chicken parmesan, with its crunchy breading and perfectly cooked chicken that leaves you craving more. It’s easy to see why one reviewer couldn’t resist sneaking fries off their son’s plate—they're simply that addictive!
Highlights also include the angry angel hair pasta with its delightful medium-spicy sauce, and the legendary lasagna, deemed the best by a first-time visitor. Each meal comes hot from the oven, ensuring that every bite is as satisfying as it is delicious. One reviewer sums it up perfectly: every dish is truly a chef's kiss!
The Stuffed Olive stands out not only for its excellent food but also for its commitment to quality. All sauces are made in-house, ensuring freshness and flavor that keeps people coming back for more. The Caesar salad dressing, prepared traditionally with anchovies, is just one of the many in-house creations that reflect their dedication to authentic Italian cuisine.
Whether you're a longtime fan or a curious newcomer, one thing is certain: the experience at The Stuffed Olive is worth every moment. Be sure to make a reservation—this bustling locale fills up quickly, and you won’t want to miss out on what many consider the best culinary experience in Eagle. Come for the food, stay for the family-like atmosphere, and leave with a heart full of satisfaction. It's time to explore why The Stuffed Olive has captured the hearts and appetites of so many!
Book a table